The Cleaning Products You Use, Part 2 ..or "1986, When Everything Changed"

Discussion in 'the CleAn Room' started by Jim Pemberton, Oct 14, 2016.

By Jim Pemberton on Oct 14, 2016 at 7:23 AM
  1. Jim Pemberton
    Jim Pemberton

    MB Exclusive.

    Joined:
    Oct 7, 2006
    Messages:
    7,715
    Name:
    Jim Pemberton
    I appreciate all of the comments under the "Cleaning Products You Use, Part 1" Thread.

    It seems that most all of us were prespraying carpet with pH 11 or 12 products, hosing down stinky carpets with cationic based quats, and were blissfully unaware of what would happen next.

    At the risk writing yet another epic, suffice to say that the introduction of stain resistant carpet, especially the heavily promoted Stainmaster product by DuPont, in 1986 created a massive change in our industry.

    Through the work of some politically adept and charismatic manufacturing industry ambassadors, we were told at industry events and in trade journals that we had to change everything we did, and there were dark, if vaguely worded, warnings of the consequences for not following these new rules:

    Products had to have a pH of "less than 10" (more on this later)
    Cleaning temperatures had to be no more than 150 degrees
    Deodorizers could not be cationic
    Deodorizers could not be applied after cleaning, but instead before
    Protectors had to be "approved"
    Cleaners needed to be certified

    How did those who were present when "the asteroid hit" respond?
    Matt Wood likes this.

Comments

Discussion in 'the CleAn Room' started by Jim Pemberton, Oct 14, 2016.

    1. Mark Saiger
      Mark Saiger

      Mr Happy!

      Joined:
      Dec 26, 2006
      Messages:
      9,324
      Location:
      Grand Rapids, MN
      Name:
      Mark Saiger
      For us, it seems the new carpet was slow to arrive in the North but at this point, I was heavily involved as a Band director...and had just sold my carpet cleaning business.

      But I need to get together with my family via phone to have another discussion.

      I think it was at that point we were concerned about it, but also were all saying "What?!"

      I do kind of remember when reapplication of Scotch Guard came out...

      Our family did purse education and certification... But after so many changes, we gave up certifications.

      Most of the family was at Master Status... But that really didn't matter to our clientele... But more for us. As an education family we respected the educational and knowledge part, but we felt, just because you changed what it took to be certified, didn't take away our already learned knowledge.

      But on the chemistry side, I will find this out...
    2. Lee Stockwell
      Lee Stockwell

      FOJL

      Joined:
      Oct 7, 2006
      Messages:
      14,109
      Location:
      Benton KY USA
      Name:
      Lee Stockwell
      A perfect storm for us, two years into our association with Bane Clene.
      billyeadon likes this.
    3. Jimmy L
      Jimmy L

      Member

      Joined:
      Oct 7, 2006
      Messages:
      10,659
      Location:
      Ne
      Name:
      Jimmy L
      Yeah the rules changed to suit the chem makers so they could flood the market with " Miracle" chems.
      I see the more experienced carpet cleaners going back to a more simpler time leaving the marketing BS behind. Using those hi ph chems especially in apartments or restuarants and even residential because they work. Look at saiger's sauce what ph is that? Acid rinse bla bla bla. I can see it in some circumstances but the majority.....no.

      Sometimes the old way is better don't over think it because it's only a 1/2 of plastic fiber.
      vibra-vacster and Bob Pruitt like this.
    4. Dennis99
      Dennis99

      Member

      Joined:
      Mar 25, 2009
      Messages:
      17
      Location:
      Gorleston, Norfolk, UK
      Name:
      Dennis
      I started out with a Chem-Dry franchise back in 1990 and if I remember right their pre-spray then was Formula 5 and was sold as safe on "5th Generation" carpets. Now there was some marketing BS. :biggrin:
    5. Bob Pruitt
      Bob Pruitt

      Member

      Joined:
      May 22, 2016
      Messages:
      2,060
      Location:
      earth
      Name:
      Robert Pruitt
      We were on the West Coast. We kept on using the same products and cleaning the way we always had.
      The Trade Associations had little input into my business but I took some classes because I enjoyed doing that...not that I can remember learning anything that actually made us money in those classes. I sent a couple of employees to get certified but both of them didn't last long with us and it was expensive - fee for the class and another fee to test.I don't think there was a single thing taught at the Certification classes that I didn't already teach. Certification felt like an expensive scam.

      The Chemicals we bought were the same but the chem makers added Safe for StainMaster Carpets and other marketing words...maybe they buffered the chemicals... I don't know. We had joined the SCT early on and had a big binder that was added to/mailed monthly from Ed York.
      That was a serious group for it's time and the information was helpful.
      billyeadon, scottw, Jimmy L and 2 others like this.
    6. Mikey P
      Mikey P

      Administrator

      Joined:
      Oct 6, 2006
      Messages:
      70,730
      Location:
      The High Chapperal
      Name:
      Mike Pay-oh-tay
      I vaguely recall a tech meetint at Coit where the manager said something about this.
      It may have been around the time where the company changed product lines.

      I had a Hydro-Force by then but still no vacuum or a scrubber.


      We were told to respond to inquiries with a "Yes, our Cleaning solutions are compliant"..
      Jimmy L and Mark Saiger like this.
    7. Matt Wood
      Matt Wood

      Member

      Joined:
      Feb 4, 2016
      Messages:
      4,181
      Location:
      Georgia
      Name:
      matt wood
      Are you saying that Shaw or Mohawk or both opened their wallets and paid prochem, chenspec, etc. to adjust their Chems and directions for how to clean so the carpet would wear out faster????

      It makes sense to me
    8. Jim Pemberton
      Jim Pemberton

      MB Exclusive.

      Joined:
      Oct 7, 2006
      Messages:
      7,715
      Name:
      Jim Pemberton
      Not at all Matt.

      The fiber producers at the time (each have sold the divisions and aren't directly involved as they were then) were DuPont, Monsanto, and Allied. They directed the need to create cleaning agents that wouldn't harm the stain resistant coating.

      What we ended up with at first was less than effective ( to say it kindly ), what we settled on later just didn't damage it as much, but did damage the stain resistant materials more than most realized. More on that later.
      Mark Saiger and Matt Wood like this.
    9. Lee Stockwell
      Lee Stockwell

      FOJL

      Joined:
      Oct 7, 2006
      Messages:
      14,109
      Location:
      Benton KY USA
      Name:
      Lee Stockwell
      One great Bane memory is the series of mill tours they arranged.

      J&J in Dalton specialized in commercial and high end modules, and their tour (86) included R&D trends way ahead of most others.

      Lees in Virginia, then the world's largest carpet manufacturing plant, was screen printing custom modules, among other innovative ideas. I still remember an engineer in our small group giving me a strong push toward clear rinsing.

      We also toured DuPont's nylon plant in DE and Monsanto's in AL.

      Several tours on Shaw's R&D in the Cindy Sayre era, always fun.

      Good memories!
      billyeadon and Mark Saiger like this.
    10. Cleanworks
      Cleanworks

      Member

      Joined:
      Oct 22, 2012
      Messages:
      7,819
      Location:
      New Westminster,BC
      Name:
      Ron Marriott
      In 1987 I was certiified as a DuPont technician which meant I was qualified to clean ans apply DuPont Teflon protector. I actually received several jobs from the DuPont referral service to try and remove stains from their Stainmaster carpet. I remember one distinctly, the customer had a Kool aid stain that they had tried to clean and had smeared everywhere. We were unable to remove it completely and DuPont replaced all the carpet on the whole lower floor of the house.
      scottw likes this.
    11. Desk Jockey
      Desk Jockey

      Rico Suave

      Joined:
      Oct 9, 2006
      Messages:
      55,789
      Location:
      a planet far far away
      Name:
      Mr Misunderstood
      Masterseries products initially until it all settled out. Since then Prochem's Axiom line
    12. SamIam
      SamIam

      Supportive Member

      Joined:
      Aug 9, 2012
      Messages:
      7,200
      Location:
      California
      Name:
      sam miller
      Chemspec kill odor plus was a good product better then regular kill odor.

      Better then spring fresh duo.

      We were a porty company there was never an issue with heat.

      But citric acid saved are butts a few times
      Jimmy L likes this.
    13. Mikey P
      Mikey P

      Administrator

      Joined:
      Oct 6, 2006
      Messages:
      70,730
      Location:
      The High Chapperal
      Name:
      Mike Pay-oh-tay
      your training program sucked.
    14. Jim Pemberton
      Jim Pemberton

      MB Exclusive.

      Joined:
      Oct 7, 2006
      Messages:
      7,715
      Name:
      Jim Pemberton
      In retrospect, the "experts" didn't get it.

      The 150 degree upper limit was based on tests done of temperatures left on the fiber surface, not what read on the temperature gauge. Few machines can keep that sort of temperature on the fiber surface unless it's kept under constant flow with a rotary jet extractor.

      The first products that were nearly neutral and included stain resist chemistry to "replenish" the fibers stain resistance didn't clean well and foamed terribly.

      The later compromises of "less than 10" provided better cleaning, but if you tested the stain resistance on the fibers afterward, it was damaged....

      So what it came down to is that we weren't "wiping the stain resistance out" at 11 or 12, but we were fooling ourselves that our "less than 10" products were "Stain Resist Safe".

      Not that it mattered, traffic wiped it out worse....

      More to come.
      SamIam, Jimmy L, Mark Saiger and 3 others like this.
    15. Radar Foster
      Radar Foster

      Mr Personality

      Joined:
      Oct 9, 2006
      Messages:
      8,580
      Location:
      Stoughton,MA
      Name:
      Fred Boyle
      Show up on time, in uniform, and provide superior results with a smile and personality


      The rest is just noise



      And Blane Crene was FOS
    16. Mikey P
      Mikey P

      Administrator

      Joined:
      Oct 6, 2006
      Messages:
      70,730
      Location:
      The High Chapperal
      Name:
      Mike Pay-oh-tay
      In uniform?


      naw..

      The right smile and conversationalist skills will never give the lady a chance to notice what the hell you have on.


      Assuming you have pants and a clean shirt with sleeves on..
      Jim Pemberton likes this.
    17. Radar Foster
      Radar Foster

      Mr Personality

      Joined:
      Oct 9, 2006
      Messages:
      8,580
      Location:
      Stoughton,MA
      Name:
      Fred Boyle
      May work for the owner, but I still believe employees can use the extra symbol of competence that at least a Company Tshirt and Jacket provides
    18. Mikey P
      Mikey P

      Administrator

      Joined:
      Oct 6, 2006
      Messages:
      70,730
      Location:
      The High Chapperal
      Name:
      Mike Pay-oh-tay
      I'm blessed with lady killers...
    19. Onfire_02_01
      Onfire_02_01

      Member

      Joined:
      Jan 2, 2016
      Messages:
      718
      Location:
      Minnesota
      Name:
      Jeremy Gray
      How about the "Naked Man" from how I met your mother?
      Pioneer Floorcare likes this.

Share This Page