The size, not the physical size, but the
CCA and the Amp Hour rating is something that should be carefully determined depending on the individual situation.
Most of the time bigger is better, but not always.
Bigger should not completely compensate for a undersized charging system or a high running load. Deep Cycle batteries are not the best choice for starting applications, nor is every TM setup a "starting" battery situation.
First determine these:
1. Cold Cranking Amps required for starting in the most adverse conditions that will be encountered.
2. The typical running load.
3. The maximum running load, with Auto Pump unit and/or electric hose reel running.
4. Will the charging system handle the max load during running? In other words, will the charging system handle the Auto Pumpout running, along with the other needs, including charging the battery?
Ordinarily a size 24, with a fairly medium size AH and
CCA rating will suffice. However, you may find that you are radically treating your existing battery very poorly compared with the charge/discharge paradigm it was designed for.
Sometimes it proves to be a wise choice to choose a battery designed for starting, but with dual purpose deep cycle capability.
Deep Cycle batteries have thicker lead plates than starting batteries. Ordinarily though, they do not make the best choice for starting applications, because shallow cycling has a tendency to have a detrimental effect on longevity. They do make batteries though that work a happy medium.
Gel Batteries or Absorbed Glass Mat(AGM) usually have a much better plate support system for the plates and are more physically durable. The captive electrolyte has better control over chemical reactions, so the longevity is much better, and they don't require maintenance. They are sealed, and the electrolyte level is maintained such that the plates are never exposed to corrosive conditions. Definitely worth looking at.
The bottom line is that battery selection is pretty individual, what doesn't work is usually the result of wrong selection of amp hours mixed with the high amp loading that some setups have. Rarely is it a simple question of cold cranking amps.