Bane Clene

[Andy]

How does a Bane unit compare to a PORTABLE not a truckmount?

 

[hogjowl]

I’m trying to think of someone, who’s still here, that had experience with one.
Stockwell has gone silent and Boyle has been banished.

 

[Jim Pemberton]

How does a Bane unit compare to a PORTABLE not a truckmount?

I grew up with the company as a competitor, and the owner, Bill Bane, as a business friend.

Which model are you speaking of?

What portable are you thinking of comparing it to?

 

[Mikey P]

I’m trying to think of someone, who’s still here, that had experience with one.
Stockwell has gone silent and Boyle has been banished.

Lee hits a lot of likes..

 

[LOV3Y]

i am familiar with the banes.
it still haunts me in my nightmares.

have a local "friend" (hack) that just bought a "new one"

they are trash compared to modern machines. i would personally bring a portable in a house over using a "truck mount" bane "clean"

what is it, 70 psi with water that cant go higher than 165 without destroying the stater?

 

[hogjowl]

Years ago, probably in the mid 90’s, I met a dude who bought a brand new one and started a business up on Lake Martin. Million $ homes area. I tried talking to him but he really had an off-putting attitude about him. I realized later that Bane taught that attitude to all his new peeps in the cult. The guy disappeared after a couple of years.

I have a high school “friend” whose daughter has just gone into the maid business. I told him to tell her to get up with me after she’s established and I’d give her a good add-on possibly that would fit into what she’s going to be doing but would tripple her hourly rate.
He didn’t even respond. Either he thinks as highly of me as I do him, or she’s bought a franchise and is in the cult indoctrination period as we speak.

 

[Jim Pemberton]

I realized later that Bane taught that attitude to all his new peeps in the cult.

Their newsletters were the greatest.

They mixed some folksy editorials, fairly good relationship marketing ideas (for the era), and general "Norman Rockwell" vibe that attracted many.

They also made sure that they "understood" that suppliers other than they themselves were shady, and other cleaners either mislead or dangerous to associate with.

My favorite was their snide take down of the then "SCT" (Society of Cleaning Technicians)

They called it:

Society of
Heat
Injection
Technicians



Norman Rockwell Americana indeed....

 

[hogjowl]

Stockwell is a red headed JW and used to be a bane clean dude.
I’m surprised we can live with him.

 

[Lee Stockwell]

Stockwell is a red headed JW and used to be a bane clean dude.
I’m surprised we can live with him.

Did ditching the Bane help?

 

[Nomad74]

Lee likes my posts. I like Lee. Be more like Lee.

 

[Nate The Great]

Lee's Bane is Tornado tough, proven to withstand anything it can throw at it..

What type of work are you looking to do with a bane? I'm sure there are better options available..

 

[Andy]

Just curious how they would compare, apples to apples, if i had a job that required absolute security, (ie. doors locked). Portability and ease of use.

 

[hogjowl]

Portability … LOL
I’m told those things are heavy.

 

[Jim Pemberton]

Portability … LOL
I’m told those things are heavy.

Extremely.

All high performance portables are heavy, but today's units usually have large back wheels to make them easier to push and to take up stairs or at least up over a curb.

The Bane unit, unless massively redesigned, is on casters or small wheels, hasn't that ease of use.

Put another way by someone who has gone to the Marty Sutley school of wit:

"It is as portable as a refrigerator on wheels is portable"

 

[Nate The Great]

I've had the pleasure of using the WorkMaster ETM.. Having to unload it and move it around at a young age, I'm thankful for smaller portables.. How does Bane heat the water?

 

[Cleanworks]

Did ditching the Bane help?

Is the hair still red?

 

[Cleanworks]

Extremely.

All high performance portables are heavy, but today's units usually have large back wheels to make them easier to push and to take up stairs or at least up over a curb.

The Bane unit, unless massively redesigned, is on casters or small wheels, hasn't that ease of use.

Put another way by someone who has gone to the Marty Sutley school of wit:

"It is as portable as a refrigerator on wheels is portable"

I can take a refrigerator up stairs as long as I have a good dolly. I wouldn't attempt it with a Bane.

 

[Jim Pemberton]

I can take a refrigerator up stairs as long as I have a good dolly. I wouldn't attempt it with a Bane.

That was the guys point.

A refigerator on wheels versus a dolly.

All things equal, it was machine for another time, not ours.

 

[Lee Stockwell]

I came away from my enjoyable Bane experience with some great insights!

First of all, it isn't about the machine, no matter the choice you make. more...

 

[JS41035]

Ugh. Bane. Proof you can get anything clean if you scrub it enough. The best part of Bane was that they made you believe you had the best system around. Don’t worry about chemicals or upgrading or improving equipment. Just focus on getting customers and your business. That worked before the internet. I remember the first time I tried Duane Oxleys propane fired TM. It was impossible to stay with Bane. All the Bogus stuff about how dangerous Gas machines were was gone.
Bane had an amazing opportunity. They had a system. All the Chems and equipment were branded perfect. Add to that the education system they had. And all the marketing. Imagine if they had kept evolving the actual equipment. But they turned out to be like Ford Motor company if it refused to ever change the Model T

 

[Jim Pemberton]

Ugh. Bane. Proof you can get anything clean if you scrub it enough. The best part of Bane was that they made you believe you had the best system around. Don’t worry about chemicals or upgrading or improving equipment. Just focus on getting customers and your business. That worked before the internet. I remember the first time I tried Duane Oxleys propane fired TM. It was impossible to stay with Bane. All the Bogus stuff about how dangerous Gas machines were was gone.
Bane had an amazing opportunity. They had a system. All the Chems and equipment were branded perfect. Add to that the education system they had. And all the marketing. Imagine if they had kept evolving the actual equipment. But they turned out to be like Ford Motor company if it refused to ever change the Model T

Well put.

Had they developed an even moderately powered machine, and/or franchised, they would still be a powerhouse.

Bill Bane and the founder of Stanley Steemer both went to trade shows selling their machines against the Prochems, Steam Genies, Hydramasters, and Big Reds. The Stanley Steemer owner pulled back and made a franchise. Bill Bane pulled back and did his own thing.

Stanley Steemer obviously made the better move.

 

[Kenny Hayes]

I used to use one in my classrooms. I used the Ultra port with a little giant on a dolly. It dang sure got the 150 psi water hot. My Bane unit had one cord. I believe the current units have two. There’s really no upside to one over a high performance portable at all. Zero.

 

[Kenny Hayes]

I never bought the kool-aid about the other stuff. I always used regular chems from my distributor. I did get some razzing about using one from my disty just because

 

[WolvrinFan98]

How does a Bane unit compare to a PORTABLE not a truckmount

Imo The bane unit is far superior to the average portable unit. You can clean entire homes with one tank if the chemicals are mixed properly. The only issue is figuring out that you need to work away from the machine to avoid hoses piling up.

 

[Kenny Hayes]

What does chemical mixture have to do with how much use you get from a tank. I might know the thought?

 

[Matt Middleton]

Their newsletters were the greatest.

They mixed some folksy editorials, fairly good relationship marketing ideas (for the era), and general "Norman Rockwell" vibe that attracted many.

They also made sure that they "understood" that suppliers other than they themselves were shady, and other cleaners either mislead or dangerous to associate with.

My favorite was their snide take down of the then "SCT" (Society of Cleaning Technicians)

They called it:

Society of
Heat
Injection
Technicians



Norman Rockwell Americana indeed....

I remember that well.

 

[Nomad74]

Imo The bane unit is far superior to the average portable unit. You can clean entire homes with one tank if the chemicals are mixed properly. The only issue is figuring out that you need to work away from the machine to avoid hoses piling up.

Is this a joke?

 

[Kenny Hayes]

Probably not meant to be maybe

 

[they live]

My bane use to catch fire at the plug.
I had to change the electric plug a couple times a year it got so hot.
My advice buy a used butler from Brian Hannah.