Just a quick note before this account gets wiped...................
It does not matter how many competitors there are for an area if the competitors that are there are entrenched. In areas like braintree, plymouth etc you have 10+ year old domains (local/non franchise-major factor), lots of indexed content, and tons of backlinks. These things take a long time to overcome.
Also, in these areas many times it is harder to "jump" directories". I would MUCH rather work in an area with a large pop that displayed a merged 10pack and was likely to search one term and where Google gives authority/ prime position to locals.
Add to that many of the terms like "carpet cleaning plymouth" are not US specific. Competition is multinational. Just search "carpet cleaning plymouth" to see what I mean. Google's default is to the UK EVEN when the default location is set to MASS. So you are depending on a longer tail........or the short which belongs to the big dogs........
Youkum is in one of the easiest areas around. If I had access to Dirk's site and places listings Dave would move down quickly. Hell I have Dirk at 2 with NO ACCESS. (he has dropped since G did an update at midnight...but he'll be back in a few hours...bye bye pics/logos for now) With access to Gemini and others I could move him out of sight. See all the green?
Dave is a f'n joke...a lucky f'n joke but a joke nonetheless.
As for B he provides a service....one that many seem to be happy with and I'm ok with that.........although I don't completely understand it. Its more of a parlor trick, that although I'm sure he would disagree, I taught him.
To prove the point I threw up a couple things for "carpet cleaning duxbury" where we "overlap" within 12 hours I have MOST of the listings on the front page. nothing special because it was EASY. I didn't optimize or prettyize any of them but they are there. Simply a loophole in Google's quest for fresh content but they usually don't stick longterm. I can do it all day long in "minor" areas. SITES are actually harder especially when there are many targets. It is the secondary "goal" for me but I use it to push the competition down the page.
cheers,
Fred
PS..........you guys shooting for "carpet cleaning your city" are missing out....................and thats all I have to say about that. </code>