Portys that can somewhat work like a TM?

Dolly Llama

Number 5
Joined
Oct 7, 2006
Messages
30,640
Location
North East Ohio
Name
Larry Capitoni
  • Since Ofer was having fun throwing out some generic statements, I thought I would do the same!-lol

  • Yes- You can clean very well with a less expensive, Lower Cost TM
  • No- It will not clean as well as a more expensive truck mount, unless you're willing to increase all the extra component of TACT to compensate. Which eventually (through the natural process of aging, shrinking, tight schedule, loss of happiness, etc. etc.) people tend to get lackadaisical about.
  • Yes- They (lower cost less expensive TM's) do require more (not less) maintenance, as parts seem to break more often.
  • No- You don't have to (though most do) entertain suicidal thoughts while using a Cheaper TM..
  • Yes- Any job with a Lower cost TM will take you longer.
  • No- Ofer is not from Mars.
  • Bottom line, isn't it common-sense that a $9,000 TM would clean better than a $8,000-to-$8,999.00 one?

Ed, I've always had respect for you (aside from that, I've always just plain liked you)
I don't believe you've seen me say anything bad about a Recoil specifically

but it really comes down to this;

gas driven positive displacement blowers ...it's really what makes the difference
Electric vac motors can't compete on a couple/three cords
be it at 50ft or a 150ft , the PD blower will always pull stronger (assuming 36 and up running at or near max RPM/HG specs )


not a knock on anything or anybody, i promise ...it's matter of, "that's just the way it is"


..L.T.A.
 

dgardner

Moderator
Joined
Apr 7, 2008
Messages
5,109
Location
Phoenix, AZ
Name
Dan Gardner
It's a known constant - 746 watts equals one horsepower. Two 20A circuits - (if motors were 100% perfect and you could use all 20A without tripping the breaker) - gives you 6.4 horsepower - to run the vacs, pump, and any heat. That's why electric machines don't have equal performance. It's an energy thing. A TM's 20hp engine translates to 125 AMPS worth of 120V circuits. Give me that many amps and I (or anyone) can make an electric machine of equal performance to a TM.

In real life motors aren't 100% efficient and you can't actually get 20A out of a 20A circuit. If you figure 17A per circuit and 85% efficient motors you're down to about 4.7 hp.....
 

dwellpro

Supportive Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2014
Messages
157
Location
usa
Name
m
The Dwell unit has a heating element available. But I don't think you want that.. Unless you carry your own generator.
Run a heater without the high pressure motor and your Golden. 80 psi coming out of the wall. Roto-vac with flood jets? How much pressure do you use with your Roto-Vac?
What temp at the wand do truck mount operators clean with?
 

dwellpro

Supportive Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2014
Messages
157
Location
usa
Name
m
"........, two-cords worth of power just won't get you there."

Well, contrary to the honorable Larry's comment/opinion, I would respectfully disagree. Yes, I have had only 41 years in this Industry; some may consider this a "newbie" while others might consider it "experience".

Powerful? Two Cords?

I would suggest perhaps looking a little further...........................................


Best always;
Ed Valentine
cross-american corp.
The fact is pride in workmanship get it done Ed. Buyers of my machine go up against truck mounts everyday and win big. There overhead is low and the job gets done as well if not better than a truck.

Your the expert? Changed your method how many times in the 41 years? The last time you changed your method was? Has the surfaces and Dwellings being cleaned changed in this time? What temp do you clean with? Textiles cleaned should be dry in what amount of time? Do you have a gut? If so how long have you had it?
The common denominator of Dwell Pro owners are there physical appearance. I like to call it the non-lazy look. Lean and ready to move into another tax bracket. Just the facts sir.
 

dwellpro

Supportive Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2014
Messages
157
Location
usa
Name
m
No. I'm pretty sure mine has the original vac motors.. I was asking Kubasiewicz in the hardware room about them but I guess he doesn't get on here often.
Forget the heat.

You are not going to find the kind of heat output your looking for from anything that plugs into a wall… especially the amount of heat needed to keep up with the flow of a hard surface tool.


Consider how you can make up for the lack of heat using chemistry and a good scrubbin.

Auto-fill/dump is a very common, if not standard option from most manufacturers nowadays.

LTD12 is 200+ pounds.

The Dwell unit does not have any heating element.
How much heat. What tempneeds to hit the surface
 

Ed Valentine

Member
Joined
Jun 18, 2013
Messages
488
Location
Milan, MI
Name
Ed Valentine
Ofer, you too certainly are a great sport! I am very glad you did not take my comments personally because they were certainly not meant as such. Only something to think about.

I do thank all above as well. Again, all great Gentlemen. And, thanks to another well known and terrific leader in our Industry, Jim Pemberton, for his comments. (Jim, I will never forget always being you and your wonderful Fathers booth neighbor at the PA Tri-State show!)

Dwellpro, unfortunately, I apologize because I didn't quit understand what you were trying to convey? But, thanks just the same.

Best;
Ed Valentine
 

Willy P

Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
10,617
Location
Vancouver
Name
Willy P
The fact is pride in workmanship get it done Ed. Buyers of my machine go up against truck mounts everyday and win big. There overhead is low and the job gets done as well if not better than a truck.

Your the expert? Changed your method how many times in the 41 years? The last time you changed your method was? Has the surfaces and Dwellings being cleaned changed in this time? What temp do you clean with? Textiles cleaned should be dry in what amount of time? Do you have a gut? If so how long have you had it?
The common denominator of Dwell Pro owners are there physical appearance. I like to call it the non-lazy look. Lean and ready to move into another tax bracket. Just the facts sir.

You might try posting sober..
 

Willy P

Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
10,617
Location
Vancouver
Name
Willy P
And a good marketing tool is to not alienate fat bastards. Fat bastards have spending money too....
 

ruff

Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2007
Messages
11,010
Location
San Francisco, CA
Name
Ofer Kolton
The common denominator of Dwell Pro owners are there physical appearance. I like to call it the non-lazy look. Lean and ready to move into another tax bracket. Just the facts sir.


Here on MB we much prefer to refer to it as "the deer in the headlight" look.

A soon to be developed look, by all active "porty hacks" :winky:

Does the warranty include the years of therapy required due to PPSD (post porty stress disorder)?
 
Last edited:
F

FB7777

Guest
And a good marketing tool is to not alienate fat bastards. Fat bastards have spending money too....
Another is to perhaps get a proof reader for both writing errors and anger editing

Willy and I can afford to be a-holes here , we aren't selling anything
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lee Stockwell

Desk Jockey

Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2006
Messages
64,833
Location
A planet far far away
Name
Rico Suave
Does the warranty include the years of therapy required due to PPSD (post porty stress disorder)?
I've been telling you guys, working with a porty all those years will get to you. :winky:

smiley-whacky110.gif
 

Shane Deubell

Supportive Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
4,052
The common denominator of Dwell Pro owners are there physical appearance. I like to call it the non-lazy look. Lean and ready to move into another tax bracket. Just the facts sir.

This is so classic, putting this bad boy in the vault for safe keeping. :lol:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lee Stockwell

CCWorks

Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2014
Messages
47
Location
USA
Name
Greg
It's a known constant - 746 watts equals one horsepower. Two 20A circuits - (if motors were 100% perfect and you could use all 20A without tripping the breaker) - gives you 6.4 horsepower - to run the vacs, pump, and any heat. That's why electric machines don't have equal performance. It's an energy thing. A TM's 20hp engine translates to 125 AMPS worth of 120V circuits. Give me that many amps and I (or anyone) can make an electric machine of equal performance to a TM.

In real life motors aren't 100% efficient and you can't actually get 20A out of a 20A circuit. If you figure 17A per circuit and 85% efficient motors you're down to about 4.7 hp.....

I could get real truck mount performance with 60 to 70 amps using only 6 electric vacuum motors.
I could have 10 to 12 HGs and 100 to 140 CFMs when wand is 100' away using 2" hose and when the wand is on the carpet cleaning carpet.
At the base of the machine it would test to have 400 CFMs and 200" of water lift.
4, 3 stage motors at about 10 amps and two 14 amp, 2 stage motors.
Even 6, 3 stage motors at about 10 amps, 190" water lift.
Never tested, but I think it is possible.
 
Last edited:

dgardner

Moderator
Joined
Apr 7, 2008
Messages
5,109
Location
Phoenix, AZ
Name
Dan Gardner
Sure, but you still have to pump the solution - add enough amps to move 3 gpm at 1000 psi (that's about 15A right there). And you have to heat the water too - add a bunch more amps.

There's more to TM performance than moving air.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lee Stockwell

tubad sosad

Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2014
Messages
77
Location
west coast
Name
joe mama
never had a porty never want one. but i think the biggest differce is that a porty can do for example 220 cfms and 200 inchs of lift......on paper.......but not at the same time with wand on carpet. a tm can do that and more.....say 300 cfm and 15 inch of hg or 195 inchs of lift but at the same time everytime. now thats power and that is really a small tm with a 36 blower.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Desk Jockey

CCWorks

Member
Joined
Jul 17, 2014
Messages
47
Location
USA
Name
Greg
Sure, but you still have to pump the solution - add enough amps to move 3 gpm at 1000 psi (that's about 15A right there). And you have to heat the water too - add a bunch more amps.

There's more to TM performance than moving air.....
I understand what your saying one needs in the top performing systems.

To power a ETM with that many amps, I would need a 20 HP generator. A heat exchanger can be made to get the heat off the generator. May not be great heat with 3.0 gpm. but good for carpet cleaning.
 

dgardner

Moderator
Joined
Apr 7, 2008
Messages
5,109
Location
Phoenix, AZ
Name
Dan Gardner
I understand what your saying one needs in the top performing systems.
To power a ETM with that many amps, I would need a 20 HP generator. A heat exchanger can be made to get the heat off the generator. May not be great heat with 3.0 gpm. but good for carpet cleaning.

Actually, in the TM world, that would be merely average performance.

And by saying you would need a 20 hp generator to power your system you have confirmed my earlier comparison with a 20 hp TM! So we agree! :biggrin:
 

Jimmy L

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2006
Messages
15,168
Location
Ne
Name
Jimmy L
All those vac motors and when under load they struggle and slow down leaving them inept .

Whereby a blower will keep sucking until it breaks.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lee Stockwell

dgardner

Moderator
Joined
Apr 7, 2008
Messages
5,109
Location
Phoenix, AZ
Name
Dan Gardner
Actually Jimmy when put under load the electric vacs speed up (try it with any vacuum cleaner), but they do struggle..... :biggrin:
 

Willy P

Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2007
Messages
10,617
Location
Vancouver
Name
Willy P
$625 monthly contract in the common areas of a condo building. $120 2 br empty suite.Minimum service call $90. Home early enough to cook dinner. Fuel cost -$20, but we have the highest gas prices in North America at $6+ a gallon. (131.9 liter). Customers happy, I make bank. People we're pressure washing plastic and vacuuming it up. The pile in nearly all cases in less than half an inch. A properly jetted electric system will dry in 3 to 6 hours with a competent operator. It ain't rocket science.
 

Jimmy L

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2006
Messages
15,168
Location
Ne
Name
Jimmy L
Oh Willy you are so misinformed! What about the 50 bottles of chems to clean that simple little fiber? Huh?
This IS rocket science to many who STILL think that you need a degree to clean carpets! Just look at all of those youtube videos of dumasses of simpletons who just have to show you all of the steps! Some could make a 10 min, video on how to properly take the trash out of a 55 trash can. So don't tell ME..............this doesn't take a PHD to do!

MORON!

Hello Joel Hoppe! VLM klown!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Willy P

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom