RV Antifreeze VS Windshield Washer Fluid

Joined
Oct 25, 2016
Messages
2,801
Location
Montana
Name
Swani
I was curious as to which one was better for winterizing. I went to RV Antifreeze after handling regular antifreeze was to much of a pain to dispose of. What I discovered really surprised me. It's -10°F here and I set these jugs out overnight. The Super Tech I bought at Walmart for around $2.50, the Arctic Ban I bought for around $5 at my hardware store, and I think the Splash Winshield came from Lowes for around $2.50. After one night in the cold the at -10°F the Supertech that is supposed to be good till -50 is froze solid and bulged out the jug. The Arctic Ban is not quite solid but more slushy, and the Splash Winshield wash is still not froze and in liquid form. I think I'll be using windshield washer fluid from now on.

88577
 

Nomad74

Boy Sprout
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
23,461
Location
Redding
Oh my....what is that?😳
That was a Toilet tank that exploded when the water froze during this polar freeze everyone is going through. Somewhere in Wisconsin. At least it didn't flood the house.

For the record, I'm not going through a polar freeze here in California. I just ride my motorcycle around and think happy thoughts.
 

BIG WOOD

MLPW
Joined
Feb 4, 2016
Messages
13,157
Location
Georgia
Name
Matt w.
Out of all the windshield washer fluid I bought non of it has froze yet, all of the RV has. You can see in the picture of the pink RV antifreeze next to the washer fluid on there sides, the RV is bulging out. I think that could be enough to pop your heat exchanger.
View attachment 88580View attachment 88582View attachment 88581
I hope you return the frozen antifreeze jugs back to where you bought them and get your money back.
 

Jimmy L

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2006
Messages
15,162
Location
Ne
Name
Jimmy L
All I know is that superTec oil filters are made by WIX.
Don't know who makes their synthetic oil.

Don't use RV antifreeze though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Living The Dream

KevinD

Member
Joined
Nov 23, 2006
Messages
2,376
Location
Binghamton,New York
Name
Kevin Dumas
All RV antifreeze will will slush up or freeze at a certain point with some at slightly below 20 degrees.

What you are concerned with is the "Burst Point" where the product will start expanding in a sealed metal pipe
and cause damage. So a -50 degree product will not expand enough to do damage in a metal pipe until it reaches that temperature.

A bulge in a plastic container is not a good comparison to a sealed metal pipe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Living The Dream
Joined
Oct 25, 2016
Messages
2,801
Location
Montana
Name
Swani
All RV antifreeze will will slush up or freeze at a certain point with some at slightly below 20 degrees.

What you are concerned with is the "Burst Point" where the product will start expanding in a sealed metal pipe
and cause damage. So a -50 degree product will not expand enough to do damage in a metal pipe until it reaches that temperature.

A bulge in a plastic container is not a good comparison to a sealed metal pipe.
I understand that RV antifreeze will slush up, but the pink Super Tech ones are froze solid like a block of ice. You can see in the picture how it expanded all the way to the top of the jug and bulged out the bottoms. It would definitely burst the small copper pipe in a heat exchanger. The Arctic Ban is a little more slushy and I would use this again if I had to, it's actually what's in my machine right now, but I also have heaters going in there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cleanworks

FredC

Village Idiot
Joined
Jul 13, 2011
Messages
26,227
curious

Is there any concern that the methanol in the in the wiper fluid is harsher on components than the propylene glycol or ethyl alcohol of the others?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Living The Dream

DAT

Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2017
Messages
6,485
Location
Nevada
Name
Bill Cheryl
curious

Is there any concern that the methanol in the in the wiper fluid is harsher on components than the propylene glycol or ethyl alcohol of the others?
Reading about that just now.. it seems to be corrosive to aluminum, iron, steel and stainless steel..

Is there any potential contact with any of the metals mentioned when fully winterizing the TM?

Id probably still use antifreeze still because my area does not get that cold. It not corrosive either.
 

bob vawter

Grassy Knoller
Joined
Sep 15, 2007
Messages
43,689
Location
La La Land
Name
bob vawter
Hey guys...they come up wit a marvelous device that will take care of this dastardly problem....its called a.......Garage!
 

scotty747

Member
Joined
Oct 19, 2006
Messages
836
The red antifreeze is non corrosive from what I understand. a lot of newer cars use aluminum water pumps so you can replace the impeller and not the whole dam thing. I have the pink cheep rv stuff from wally world in my painting equipment but it dosent get below the 20's here usually.
 

Cleanworks

Moderator
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
26,927
Location
New Westminster,BC
Name
Ron Marriott
I wish I saw this thread sooner. I used pink -50 RV antifreeze in my CDS this winter and the heat exchanger is cracked. I haven't used it in a couple of months and was getting it ready for a job and coolant was leaking everywhere. It doesn't even get close to 0 degrees at night here.
RV antifreeze works but you have to make sure you get rid of all of the water first. You have to drain the mix tank and blow out all of the water from the heat exchangers and supply lines before adding the antifreeze. I would add directly to my mix tank and flush into a pail until I had pretty pure antifreeze, the I would keeping adding and recirculating until the unit was full. Luckily I don't have to do that anymore. RV antifreeze will freeze into a gel but usually won't expand to break pipes.
 
Joined
Aug 3, 2016
Messages
187
Location
Salt Lake City, UT
Name
Eric
RV antifreeze works but you have to make sure you get rid of all of the water first. You have to drain the mix tank and blow out all of the water from the heat exchangers and supply lines before adding the antifreeze. I would add directly to my mix tank and flush into a pail until I had pretty pure antifreeze, the I would keeping adding and recirculating until the unit was full. Luckily I don't have to do that anymore. RV antifreeze will freeze into a gel but usually won't expand to break pipes.
I emptied the waterbox and system of water before putting the antifreeze in. I didn't blow the lines out though which I guess is where I went wrong. I put in two gallons and ran it for awhile and still had at least a quarter of my waterbox filled with antifreeze. It must have gotten rock solid like the photos above.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: Living The Dream

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom